Blog

You have defined a class Point whose constructor takes two arguments: x and y. Which of the following is the correct way to create a point object of this class?

• let point = Point(100, 200);
• let point = create Point(100, 200);
• Point(let point, 100, 200);
• let point = new Point(100, 200);

For more Questions and Answers

JSE2: Module 2: Classes and Class-Based Approach Module 2 Test Exam Answers

In the context of object-oriented programming, particularly in languages like JavaScript, Python, or Java, creating an object from a class involves invoking the class constructor using the new keyword. Given the options provided, the correct way to create a Point object is let point = new Point(100, 200);. Let’s explore each option in detail to understand why this is the correct answer.

1. let point = Point(100, 200);

This option resembles how functions are called in many programming languages. Here, Point(100, 200) looks like a function call, and the result is assigned to the variable point.

Why It’s Incorrect:

• Lacks new Keyword: In languages like JavaScript or Java, the new keyword is required to create a new instance of a class. Without new, you are not actually invoking the constructor in the context of creating an object; instead, you are just calling a function.
• No Object Creation: If Point were a regular function, calling it this way would simply execute the function’s code and return whatever the function returns. However, if Point is a class, this code would not create a new object and would likely result in an error or unexpected behavior.

In Python, though, calling Point(100, 200) would be correct because Python doesn’t require the new keyword, and Point() directly calls the constructor. However, since the question format and syntax hint at a language like JavaScript or Java, this option is not correct for those languages.

2. let point = create Point(100, 200);

This option introduces the word “create” before the Point class, which might imply that it is trying to use a special syntax or function to create an object.

Why It’s Incorrect:

• Invalid Syntax: The word “create” is not a recognized keyword in any major programming language (JavaScript, Java, Python, C#, etc.) for creating objects. It does not correspond to any standard object creation pattern or function.
• Confusing Intent: This option might confuse someone reading the code because “create” is not a standard term for object instantiation. It could imply the existence of a custom factory function named create, but that is not defined in this context, so this is not valid syntax for creating an object.

3. Point(let point, 100, 200);

This option seems to mix elements of function invocation and variable declaration, with let point appearing as an argument in what looks like a function call.

Why It’s Incorrect:

• Misuse of let: The let keyword is used in languages like JavaScript to declare a variable. In this syntax, it appears inside the parentheses, where arguments to a function or constructor would typically be placed. This is not a valid use of let.
• No new Keyword: Even if the let keyword were not present, this syntax would still be incorrect for object creation in languages like JavaScript or Java because it lacks the new keyword.
• Not a Valid Function Call: Placing let point inside what appears to be a function call is syntactically incorrect and would not be recognized by the language parser. This would likely result in a compilation or runtime error.

4. let point = new Point(100, 200);

This option is the correct way to create a new Point object in languages like JavaScript, Java, and other similar object-oriented languages.

Why It’s Correct:

• Use of new Keyword: The new keyword is crucial in languages like JavaScript and Java for object instantiation. It tells the language interpreter or compiler that you want to create a new instance of the class Point.
• Correct Syntax: The syntax new Point(100, 200) correctly invokes the constructor of the Point class, passing 100 and 200 as arguments. The constructor initializes the object with these values, and the object is assigned to the variable point.
• Object Creation: This syntax ensures that a new Point object is created, with its x and y properties set according to the constructor’s parameters. The variable point now holds a reference to this newly created object.

Conclusion

The correct way to create a Point object from the Point class, assuming you are working in a language like JavaScript or Java, is let point = new Point(100, 200);. This syntax is standard across many object-oriented programming languages that use the new keyword for object instantiation.

The other options—let point = Point(100, 200);, let point = create Point(100, 200);, and Point(let point, 100, 200);—are all incorrect for various reasons, primarily related to improper syntax, misuse of keywords, or misunderstanding of how objects are instantiated in these languages.

Additional Considerations

While the new keyword is critical in some languages, it is worth noting that different programming languages have different conventions for object creation. For example:

• Python: In Python, the new keyword is not required, and the object is created directly by calling the class name with the required arguments (e.g., point = Point(100, 200)).
• Ruby: In Ruby, objects are created using Point.new(100, 200).

Understanding the specific syntax and conventions of the programming language you are using is essential for correctly creating and managing objects within that language.